Upward feedback

Upward feedback that managers can act on

Let each team rate its manager anonymously on the things only a team sees: one-to-ones, delegation, feedback and support. Every manager gets a clear report and a short plan, and HR sees manager effectiveness across the company.

Why upward feedback

What only the team can tell a manager

Feedback from below

Direct reports see a side of their manager that peers and bosses never do. Upward feedback puts that view in front of the manager, in words they can use.

Safe to be honest

Answers are stored with no link to who gave them, and results only show when at least three people answer. No one on the team can be singled out.

Questions written for the team

Questions such as “Gives me ownership of outcomes, not just tasks” go to direct reports only, written from their point of view.

Better comments

Before they submit, raters can see tips that make a comment more useful or less likely to give them away. They always decide what is sent.

A plan, not a score

The report puts strengths first, then the areas to work on with things to try in the next 30 days, so managers know where to start.

See if it changed

Run a short check-in 90 days later and the team re-rates the same behaviors, so you can see what actually improved.

How it works

From survey to manager effectiveness insight

Set it up

An upward feedback survey in minutes

Start from the New manager or Leadership 360 template, or describe what you want and let AI draft the questions. Choose which questions go to direct reports only, then add each manager and their team.

  • Direct-reports-only questions in the team’s own words
  • About 10 minutes for each rater
  • Reminders and progress tracking done for you

For each manager

A report that says what to do next

Each manager sees their top strengths and the areas their team would most like to see change, how their own view compares, and what people said, grouped so no one is exposed.

  • Scores shown as words and traffic-light bars
  • Blind spots and hidden strengths
  • A development plan to fill in with their own manager

Your 360° feedback report

Maya Santos

What to do about them

What to do about them

1Makes sure quieter people get heard

What people are seeing

Colleagues rated this 2.6 out of 5, and you rated it 4.0.

Why it matters

When people feel heard they bring problems early and share their best ideas; when they don’t, they go quiet.

Try this in the next 30 days

  • In your next three meetings, summarize what you heard before you give your own view.
  • Count to three before replying when someone finishes speaking.
  • Ask “What am I missing?” at the end of each decision discussion.

You’ll know it’s working when

People bring you problems earlier, and say “thanks for hearing me out”.

For HR

Manager effectiveness across the company

Group results show where managers are strong and where they struggle as a group, without exposing any single team. Ask a question in plain English and get an answer drawn only from the grouped results.

  • Strengths and gaps across all managers
  • Compare with an earlier round
  • L&D recommendations you can share

Group results

People leaders

Q4

Your top strengths

Playing to your strengths is one of the fastest ways to grow. Check whether you agree, and compare how each group sees you. The bar is the average from everyone except you.

AreaColleagues’ averagePoorExceptionalYour viewManagerPeersDirect reports

These 5 areas were given the highest scores

Explains why the team’s goals matterVery goodExceptionalExceptionalExceptional
Shows how my work connects to the team’s goalsVery good––Exceptional
Explains where the team is headingVery goodVery goodExceptionalVery good
Sets goals that everyone involved understandsVery goodVery goodExceptionalVery good
Gives me work that stretches my skillsVery good––Very good

Example questions

Upward feedback questions that work

Each one asks about a single behavior the team can see. Copy them, or start from a template and edit.

One-to-ones and support

  • Holds one-to-ones that are useful to me
  • Listens without interrupting when I raise a concern
  • Follows through on what we agree in our one-to-ones
  • Talks with me about my career goals

Delegation and trust

  • Gives me ownership of outcomes, not just tasks
  • Makes clear what’s expected when handing work to me
  • Trusts me to do my work without close checking
  • Protects our team’s time from low-priority work

Feedback and fairness

  • Gives specific feedback that helps me improve
  • Recognizes good work when it happens
  • Explains the reasons behind decisions that affect our team
  • Makes sure quieter people in our team get heard

FAQ

Questions people ask

What is upward feedback?

Upward feedback is when employees give feedback to their manager. It usually means an anonymous survey where direct reports rate their manager on everyday behaviors such as one-to-ones, delegation, recognition and communication.

How is upward feedback different from a 360 review?

A 360 review collects feedback from the manager, peers, direct reports and the person themselves. Upward feedback focuses only on the direct reports. Many companies start with upward feedback and move to a full 360 later. Sidelight 360 can run either.

How many direct reports does a manager need?

At least three. Results for a group only show when three or more people have answered. In smaller teams, answers are merged into one group so no one can be identified.

Is upward feedback really anonymous?

Yes. In Sidelight 360, answers are stored with no link to the person who gave them, small groups are merged, and comments are shown without names. Raters also get tips if a comment might give them away.

What is a manager effectiveness survey?

It’s upward feedback run across many managers at once, so HR can see how managers are doing as a group. In Sidelight 360 each manager gets their own report, and HR sees grouped results for all of them.

Should upward feedback be used for pay or promotion?

We recommend against it. People answer more honestly when feedback is for development only. Use it to help managers improve, and keep pay and promotion decisions separate.

How much does it cost?

You pay per manager reviewed, and raters are unlimited. The Team plan covers 30 managers for $1,069 a year, and your first 3 managers are free.

Try Sidelight 360 free

Your first 3 people are free, with unlimited raters, no card and no time limit.

Start free trial