Performance review software + 360 feedback

Keep your performance review software. Add a 360 people act on.

Performance review software runs the appraisal: goals, ratings, calibration and deadlines. Sidelight 360 runs the part reviews struggle with: honest, anonymous multi-rater feedback from peers and direct reports, a report that says what to do next, and a 90-day check that behavior changed. It works alongside whatever review tool you use.

Your 360° feedback report

Maya Santos

What to do about them

What to do about them

1Makes sure quieter people get heard

What people are seeing

Colleagues rated this 2.6 out of 5, and you rated it 4.0.

Why it matters

When people feel heard they bring problems early and share their best ideas; when they don’t, they go quiet.

Try this in the next 30 days

  • In your next three meetings, summarize what you heard before you give your own view.
  • Count to three before replying when someone finishes speaking.
  • Ask “What am I missing?” at the end of each decision discussion.

You’ll know it’s working when

People bring you problems earlier, and say “thanks for hearing me out”.

The basics

What performance review software does

Performance review software (also called performance appraisal or performance evaluation software) manages the formal review cycle. Most tools cover these six jobs.

Review cycles and templates

Annual, mid-year, quarterly, project-based, probation and new-hire reviews, with deadlines, approvals and completion tracking.

Goals and OKRs

SMART goals or OKRs, often cascaded from company to team to person so everyone’s goals line up.

Ratings and calibration

Rating scales and competency ratings, then calibration sessions where managers compare ratings to keep them consistent.

Check-ins and continuous feedback

1-on-1 agendas, regular check-ins and quick feedback between reviews.

Pay and promotion

Merit and compensation cycles, promotion decisions and talent reviews such as the nine-box grid.

Reporting

Completion rates, rating distributions and review history for HR.

CalibrationManagers meet to compare and adjust ratings so one team isn’t marked harder than another.
Nine-box gridA talent review chart that plots performance against potential, used for succession planning.
OKRsObjectives and key results: a goal plus 2 to 5 measurable results that show it was met.
Check-insShort, regular manager conversations between formal reviews, often weekly or monthly.

Performance review vs performance management software. Review software focuses on the appraisal itself. Performance management software is the wider suite: reviews plus continuous feedback, 1-on-1s, goals, engagement surveys and career paths. Most vendors now sell the suite, often priced per employee per month.

Where 360 feedback fits. All of these tools judge or track performance. A 360 does something different: it shows a person how their behavior lands with the people they work with, so they can choose what to change. Gallup’s research found that only 2 in 10 employees strongly agree their performance is managed in a way that motivates them to do outstanding work. Feedback from more than one person, used for growth rather than judgment, is one way to close that gap.

Types of tools

Three ways to add 360 feedback to performance reviews

Most review tools now include some 360 or peer feedback. The question is which setup fits how you want to use it.

What to compareHR suite with a performance modulePerformance management platformSidelight 360 alongside your review tool
ExamplesBambooHR, HiBob, WorkdayLattice, 15Five, Culture Amp, Leapsome, PerformYardSidelight 360, plus any review tool
What the 360 is forUsually feeds the review and the ratingUsually feeds the review, and may support development plansDevelopment only. Kept apart from ratings and pay
Who sees answersTypically the manager and HR, depending on settingsConfigurable by admins, often the managerThe person reviewed first, by private link. Admins see progress counts only
Small groupsDepends on settingsOften an anonymity threshold for peersGroups under 3 merged into “All colleagues”, with no way to subtract
What the person getsTheir review, with feedback includedTheir review, sometimes a feedback summaryA report in plain words: top 5 strengths, top 5 areas, blind spots and what to try in 30 days
After the reviewNext cycleGoals and check-insDevelopment plan, then a 90-day impact survey where colleagues re-rate each goal
PricingPer employee, 360 may need a higher planPer employee per month, often annualPer person reviewed, raters unlimited, from $49
Best fitYou want one HR system and 360 inside reviewsYou want reviews, goals and feedback in one placeYou already have a review tool, or want 360s for leaders, managers or coaching clients without a new suite

Based on each vendor’s public product pages in November 2026. Features vary by plan and change often, so check current details with each vendor. Product names are trademarks of their owners.

By review type

How 360 feedback fits each type of performance review

Use the 360 where it adds an honest, wider view, and leave it out where it would be unfair.

Review typeHow to use a 360Our advice
Annual reviewRun a full 360 4 to 6 weeks before. The person reads the report and brings a development plan to the review.The best fit. Start with the Leadership 360 or Individual contributor template.
Mid-year or quarterly reviewA 10-question Quick 360 check-in on the goals chosen at the annual review.Re-measures progress without a full survey. Free re-runs within 12 months.
Manager reviewsAdd upward feedback: questions only direct reports answer, about 1-on-1s, delegation and career talks.See 360 reviews for managers.
Promotion or leadership readinessA 360 on the behaviors the next role needs, as one input among several.Useful for a development plan before the move. Don’t make it the only evidence.
Probation and new-hire (90-day) reviewsA short check-in at around 90 days, only if the person has worked with at least 3 people per group.Often too early for fair feedback. Make it about settling in, not pass or fail.
Performance improvement plans (PIPs)Don’t use a 360.Raters won’t be honest when a job may depend on it. Use clear goals and the manager’s documented evidence.

Rater bias

Why one-person reviews are often unfair, and how a 360 helps

Most performance appraisals rest on one manager’s judgment. These rater biases are well known.

Recency bias

The last few weeks count for more than the whole year. A 360 asks about the behavior colleagues see regularly, from several people at once.

Single-rater bias

One manager’s view reflects their own standards and how much they see. Several raters across manager, peers and direct reports balance it out.

Leniency and harshness

Some managers rate everyone high, others low. Sidelight 360 shows each group’s view side by side, and HR can spot harsh or generous groups in group results.

Halo effect

One strength colors every rating. Behavior-based questions, one observable thing per question, make people rate each behavior on its own.

In the UK, Acas guidance on reviews and appraisals recommends regular informal feedback alongside formal reviews. A development 360 a few weeks before the appraisal does both: wider feedback, and a fairer starting point for the conversation.

Signs to look for

6 signs your performance reviews need 360 feedback

Reviews rest on one person’s view

A manager sees only part of someone’s work. Peers and direct reports see how they collaborate, run meetings and handle pressure.

Managers get no upward feedback

How someone runs 1-on-1s, delegates and develops people is something only their team sees. Without upward feedback, those skills go unreviewed. Sidelight 360 has questions only direct reports answer, written from their view.

Peer feedback is too polite to use

When comments carry a name, people hold back. Anonymous answers with small groups merged give feedback people can trust.

Goals cover results, not behavior

Hitting targets matters, but so does how. Behavior-based and competency questions show what to keep doing and what to change.

Development plans are forgotten

If nothing checks progress between reviews, plans drift. A 90-day impact survey keeps them alive.

HR can’t see skill gaps across teams

Ratings don’t say why. Group results show the strengths and gaps across a team, so training goes where it’s needed.

Anonymity

What stays private, and what admins actually see

Honest 360 feedback depends on raters trusting the process. Here is exactly how Sidelight 360 handles it.

Answers aren’t linked to raters

Answers are stored under a one-way key, with no link to who gave them. No one, admins included, can look up a rater’s answers.

Small groups merge automatically

If fewer than 3 peers or direct reports answer, their ratings join “All colleagues”. The report won’t let anyone subtract one group from another to work out a person.

Admins see progress, not answers

Confidential mode is on by default. Admins see how many people in each group have answered, then reports go privately to each person.

Comments are grouped, never named

Comments appear in the person’s report under the relationship, such as Peers. A built-in check suggests rewording comments that could give the rater away.

The manager is shown as a separate group by default, and is told so before answering. More on how anonymity works.

How it fits

Add 360 feedback to your review cycle in 4 steps

  1. 6 weeks before reviews

    Describe the 360 in a sentence or pick a template. Pull rater lists from your HR system, or let people nominate raters for you to approve.

  2. 4 weeks before

    Raters answer a short anonymous survey, about 10 minutes each, in 15 languages. Reminders go out automatically until they finish.

  3. 2 weeks before

    Each person reads their feedback report privately and picks one or two goals for their development plan.

  4. In the review, and 90 days later

    The plan, not the raw scores, goes into the review conversation. At 90 days, colleagues re-rate each goal.

For HR admins

Run 360s for a whole review cycle without chasing anyone

Describe who it’s for and what matters, for example “a 360 for our new managers before the March reviews”. Sidelight drafts the questionnaire and rater list for you to check. Nothing is sent until you launch it.

  • Live completion tracking for each group
  • Automatic reminders, plus Remind now when needed
  • 5 tested templates and 82 behavior-based questions
  • Rater lists from BambooHR, HiBob or Workday, or a CSV or Excel file

Group results

Find skill gaps across a team before review season

HR and L&D see grouped results across everyone who had a 360, with the same small-group rules. No names and no comments.

Sample: 14 new managers, lowest-rated areas

Colleagues’ average on a 5-point scale. Sample data for illustration.

Gives me ownership of outcomes, not just tasks2.7
Makes sure quieter people get heard2.9
Talks with me about my career3.1
Explains why the team’s goals matter3.8
Follows through on what they commit to4.1

Ask about these results: “What should our new-manager training focus on?” Sidelight drafts an answer and L&D recommendations from the grouped numbers, for you to check before sharing.

Works alongside your tools

Keep your review software. Here’s how the hand-off works

Nothing to install in your review tool

Sidelight 360 runs on its own, so your review software, ratings and calibration stay as they are. There’s no plug-in and no data written back into it.

The development plan is the hand-off

The person shares their report or development plan with their manager by private link or PDF, and adds their goals to your review tool as usual.

Rater lists from your HR system

Sync your org chart from BambooHR, HiBob or Workday to suggest managers, peers and direct reports. Using another system? Upload a CSV or Excel list.

Invites where people work

Email invites and reminders, with Slack invites and quick answers in Slack for short surveys. More on automation and integrations.

Security and data

How your 360 data is handled

Built for anonymity

Answers are stored with no link to raters, and admins can’t open individual reports in confidential mode.

Hosted on AWS

Sidelight 360 runs on Amazon Web Services in Sydney, over encrypted HTTPS connections. Keys for connected HR systems are stored encrypted.

AI that doesn’t train on your data

AI features run on Amazon Bedrock, and your inputs aren’t used to train AI models. Every AI feature is opt-in and drafts for a person to review.

You control retention

Download reports as PDFs, and delete a 360 at any time, which removes its answers, reports and links. We act as your data processor under GDPR. Read the privacy policy.

Cost

Upgrade every seat, or pay only for the people you review?

Suite pricing is usually per employee, so adding 360s can mean paying for everyone. Sidelight 360 charges only for people reviewed.

Example: 360s for 30 managers in a 200-person companyPer-employee performance platformSidelight 360
How it’s pricedPer employee per month, billed yearlyPer person reviewed per year. Raters and questions unlimited
Example yearly costAt 15Five’s listed $11 per user per month for its Perform plan (which includes 360 feedback), 200 seats is $26,400 a yearTeam plan: $1,069 a year for 30 people reviewed
What you getA full performance suite: reviews, goals, check-ins and 360 feedback360 feedback, guided reports, development plans, impact surveys and group results. No ratings or calibration
When it’s worth itYou need a new review system anywayYou already have a review process and want better 360s

List prices from vendor pricing pages in November 2026, before discounts. The two are not like-for-like: a performance platform does much more than 360s. See our pricing.

Be honest about fit

When you need performance review software instead

Sidelight 360 isn’t the right tool if you need to rate performance, calibrate ratings across teams, run merit and compensation cycles, plan succession with a nine-box grid, or keep a formal record of each appraisal. Performance review software does those jobs. Many teams use both: the review tool for decisions, and Sidelight 360 for honest feedback and development.

Before you buy

8 questions to ask any vendor about 360 feedback in reviews

  1. Can an admin or manager see who gave which answer?And what happens when only two peers respond? The safe answer is that their ratings merge into a larger group.
  2. Will 360 answers feed ratings or pay?If so, tell raters. Feedback stays most honest when it’s used for development.
  3. Who sees the report first?The person reviewed should see it first, and choose what to share.
  4. Who writes the questions?Each should describe one behavior colleagues can see, not a trait like “confident”.
  5. Does the report say what to do next?Ask for a sample. Charts alone rarely change behavior.
  6. How will we know if anything changed?Look for a development plan and a re-measure, not just another 360 next year.
  7. Is 360 included in our plan, and how is it priced?Per employee, per person reviewed or per rater? Does it need a higher tier?
  8. Where is the data stored, and is it used to train AI?Ask for the region, the retention policy and how deletion works.

FAQ

Questions people ask

What is performance review software?

Performance review software runs a company’s review cycle: review templates and deadlines, self-reviews, manager ratings, goals or OKRs, calibration and often pay decisions. It keeps reviews on schedule, tracks completion and stores the record of each performance appraisal.

What’s the difference between performance review and performance management software?

Performance review software focuses on the review cycle itself. Performance management software is broader: it adds continuous feedback, check-ins and 1-on-1s, goals and OKRs, engagement surveys, career paths and sometimes compensation. Most vendors now sell the broader suite.

Is Sidelight 360 performance review software?

No. Sidelight 360 doesn’t do manager ratings, calibration or pay. It runs anonymous 360 feedback and development plans that sit alongside your reviews, and it works with any review process or tool.

Do Lattice, 15Five, Culture Amp, BambooHR or HiBob include 360 feedback?

Yes. Each lists 360, peer or upward feedback as part of its performance product, sometimes only on a higher plan (BambooHR, for example, puts 360° feedback in its Pro plan). The difference is how it’s used: inside those tools, 360 answers usually feed the review. Sidelight 360 keeps them separate, for development, with a guided report and a 90-day re-measure.

Can managers see raw comments?

Not in Sidelight 360 by default. Confidential mode, which is on by default, sends each report privately to the person reviewed. Admins see progress counts, not answers. Comments appear in the person’s report grouped by relationship, never with a name, and the person chooses what to share. Group results for HR never include comments.

Should the 360 go inside the review form?

We recommend keeping it separate. When raters know their answers go straight into someone’s rating, they soften them. Run the 360 a few weeks before the review, and bring the person’s development plan into the review conversation instead of the scores.

How many raters should each person have?

Aim for 8 to 12: their manager, 3 to 5 peers and 3 to 5 direct reports if they manage people. Any group with fewer than 3 answers is merged into “All colleagues” so no one can be singled out.

Should 360 feedback affect ratings or pay?

We recommend not. Feedback tied to pay becomes less honest. Use the 360 to set development goals, and judge performance on results and progress against those goals. Our guide to 360 performance reviews explains how.

How much does Sidelight 360 cost?

It’s priced per person reviewed, with unlimited raters: $49 for a single 360, or yearly plans from $469 for 12 people and $1,069 for 30. Your first 3 people are free, with no card and no time limit. See pricing.

Try Sidelight 360 free

Your first 3 people are free, with unlimited raters, no card and no time limit.

Start free trial